Thursday, January 10, 2013

Zero.  None.  Zip.

That's how many of the greats of baseball who were eligible to be voted into the Hall of Fame got the requisite number of votes from the Baseball Writers of America Association.  Some say it was the fact that the best of the players on the ballot had career statistics tainted by steroid or other performance-enhancing drug use.  Barry Bonds, Roger Clemens, Mark McGwire and Sammy Sosa are among the names on that ballot who appear to have had their careers tainted by these allegations.

But is it fair?  Here's a look at the ballot the writers were voting on and the tally of votes (names in italics either didn't get 5% of votes or were in the last of 15 years of eligibility):

Ballots Cast: 569 Needed for Election: 427
VOTESPLAYERPERCENTAGE
388Craig Biggio68.20%
385Jack Morris67.70%
339Jeff Bagwell59.60%
329Mike Piazza57.80%
297Tim Raines52.20%
272Lee Smith47.80%
221Curt Schilling38.80%
214Roger Clemens37.60%
206Barry Bonds36.20%
204Edgar Martinez35.90%
191Alan Trammell33.60%
123Larry Walker21.60%
118Fred McGriff20.70%
106Dale Murphy18.60%
96Mark McGwire16.90%
75Don Mattingly13.20%
71Sammy Sosa12.50%
50Rafael Palmeiro8.80%
19Bernie Williams3.30%
18Kenny Lofton3.20%
16Sandy Alomar Jr.2.80%
6Julio Franco1.10%
5David Wells0.90%
4Steve Finley0.70%
2Shawn Green0.40%
1Reggie Sanders0.20%
1Aaron Sele0.20%
0Jeff Cirillo0.00%
0Royce Clayton0.00%
0Jeff Conine0.00%
0Roberto Hernandez0.00%
0Ryan Klesko0.00%
0Jose Mesa0.00%
0Mike Stanton0.00%
0Todd Walker0.00%
0Rondell White0.00%
0Woody Williams0.00%

Sean Green is a good example of players who had good, but not Hall of Fame careers.  He did hit more than 300 home runs but that's not that special.  He never had a 50 home run season.  He only drove in 100 or more RBIs in a season four times and never more than 125.  Those just aren't HOF numbers.

Craig Biggio on the other hand reached one of those career milestones that have historically lead to selection for the Hall.  He passed the 3,000 hit mark, finishing with 3,060.  He had a career that deserves enshrinement, although perhaps not on his first year of eligibility.  The question is, did he not make it because of the issue of steroids.  I think that's exactly what happened.

Barry Bonds may someday make the Hall.  He was a great player before he got "roided" up.  But I don't see a Hall of Fame induction in the futures of Sammy Sosa, Mark McGwire or Rafael Palmeiro.  They are 'tainted'.

What do you think?